Go Back   Suijuris Forums > Educational & Learning > Banks, Collectors, and CRAs
User Name
Password

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 09-26-2004, 10:04 PM
joma44 joma44 is offline
Waking Up
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 23
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan



Okay so heres the short intro.



2 years ago Original loan app was with bank of America, got turned down for credit so I guess Key Bank decided to pick it up. I never once filled out any information for Key Bank. I asked for a verification of debt in regards to a car loan with an original creditor. They sent a photocopy of the bank of america loan agreement, payment history and checks. I sent back the 9 page VOD and changed a few things. Removed the copyright stuff, added some stronger language on only accepting the original bona fide signature note and added 4 stronger questions to the offer of performance. (check the mbna turns to attorneys post to get an idea of what I asked for).



Heres what I got back along with the photocopied crap again. Any and all thoughts would be helpful. there are a couple a questions at the end of the letter. Oh yeah ICE thanks for the warning on this before hand; just because I went through with it doesn’t mean I wasn’t listening or paying attention I’m waiting for the tom schauf books and figured I’d give it a shot before they got here. Cant learn anything without trying.









KeyBank law group KeyBank USA, National Association



Dear mr. X



This letter is in response to the following packet of documents dated sept 13, 2004 that you sent to keybank: a “private international administrative remedy demand” which contained a request to validate your debt, a tender of payment and other miscellaneous items.



Please be advised that keybank is a bank and, as such, is exempt from the provisions of the fair debt Collection practices Act (FDCPA) since we are not considered to be a “debt collector,” as defined by the act. 15 USC Section 1692g. Further, since you have not been contacted by a “debt collector” section 809 of the FDCPA pertaining to the validation of a debt is not applicable to your situation. As such KeyBank will not be completing the “debt collector Disclosure Statement” that you included in your packet of information. However, KeyBank is willing to assist you in obtaining the information that you’ve requested.



Enclosed for your review are: the application for credit; the installment loan note dated November 16.2002 (”Note”); a letter from KeyBank dated November 27, 2002 indicating that the Note had been assigned to KeyBank; a copy of the payment history on this account; copies of at least five checks that were sent in as payment on this account.



Pursuant to the fair debt Collection practice Act, this letter and its enclosures serve to validate the debt that you dispute.



Additionally, please be advised that KeyBank will not accept the “tender of Payment” the “offer of Performance,” or the “certified Promissory Note” that you sent in your package. All offers of settlement on your account are hereby rejected. Your Letter dated September 13, 2004 neither acts as a novation nor as an accord and satisfaction. Further attempts at a novation or an accord and satisfaction will be similarly rejected.



We request that you stop sending further documents of this sort to KeyBank. Despite that redemption documents you have sent to KeyBank, you will remain liable for repaying your debt. In the event that you fail to repay your debt, KeyBank will take all actions available, including the possible reporting of adverse information to the various credit reporting agencies and foreclosure of your property.



KeyBank is under no obligation to provide you with any responses or acknowledgements to any letters you might send. By not providing you with any reply, KeyBank is not admitting to the truth or falsity of any statements or claims you make in your correspondence. Further, no responding to your correspondence does not create any type of default, material misrepresentation, or dishonor on the part KeyBank. Your obligation to repay the amount owed under the terms of your extension of credit are not affected by KeyBanks’s response or lack of response to any correspondence you may send in.



Please feel free to contact our Collections and Recovery Department at xxx to make payment arrangements on your account. Should you have any further questions on your account, feel free to contact one of our customer represantitives at xxx



Sincerely

KeyBank Law Group









1. Due to outright rejection of my promissory note my debt is discharged according to the UCC § 3-603. TENDER OF PAYMENT, right?



2. paragraph 7 .. Your obligation to repay the amount owed under the terms of your extension of credit…did they just admit that they the bank extended me credit????? That’s a no-no for banks right?



3. Lien, Lien who’s got the Lien. I’m still befuddled on which way to go with the removal of Keybank as legal owner on the title. On the original bank of America document I didn’t check the box or initial the box that said I would give them security interest in the property whoopsie . Also my copy of the odometer disclosure release of interest by registered owner paperwork is signed only by me. However when I went to my dealer and checked my sales file per TILA (truth in lending act) their copy of this paperwork is signed. They signed it after I left. The application says on the left hand side that applicable sections not valid unless fully completed. Are they legally allowed to give me a copy of their unsigned copy and sign it later? Can I use this letter and a copy of the promissory note I sent as a way to sue for release of Lien?



As always thank you for your responses and I’m waiting on the schauf books.

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 09-27-2004, 12:08 PM
PJT04
 
Posts: n/a
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

Quote:
Originally Posted by joma44


Okay so heres the short intro.



2 years ago Original loan app was with bank of America, got turned down for credit so I guess Key Bank decided to pick it up. I never once filled out any information for Key Bank. I asked for a verification of debt in regards to a car loan with an original creditor. They sent a photocopy of the bank of america loan agreement, payment history and checks. I sent back the 9 page VOD and changed a few things. Removed the copyright stuff, added some stronger language on only accepting the original bona fide signature note and added 4 stronger questions to the offer of performance. (check the mbna turns to attorneys post to get an idea of what I asked for).



Heres what I got back along with the photocopied crap again. Any and all thoughts would be helpful. there are a couple a questions at the end of the letter. Oh yeah ICE thanks for the warning on this before hand; just because I went through with it doesn’t mean I wasn’t listening or paying attention I’m waiting for the tom schauf books and figured I’d give it a shot before they got here. Cant learn anything without trying.









KeyBank law group KeyBank USA, National Association



Dear mr. X



This letter is in response to the following packet of documents dated sept 13, 2004 that you sent to keybank: a “private international administrative remedy demand” which contained a request to validate your debt, a tender of payment and other miscellaneous items.



Please be advised that keybank is a bank and, as such, is exempt from the provisions of the fair debt Collection practices Act (FDCPA) since we are not considered to be a “debt collector,” as defined by the act. 15 USC Section 1692g. Further, since you have not been contacted by a “debt collector” section 809 of the FDCPA pertaining to the validation of a debt is not applicable to your situation. As such KeyBank will not be completing the “debt collector Disclosure Statement” that you included in your packet of information. However, KeyBank is willing to assist you in obtaining the information that you’ve requested.



Enclosed for your review are: the application for credit; the installment loan note dated November 16.2002 (”Note” a letter from KeyBank dated November 27, 2002 indicating that the Note had been assigned to KeyBank; a copy of the payment history on this account; copies of at least five checks that were sent in as payment on this account.



Pursuant to the fair debt Collection practice Act, this letter and its enclosures serve to validate the debt that you dispute.



Additionally, please be advised that KeyBank will not accept the “tender of Payment” the “offer of Performance,” or the “certified Promissory Note” that you sent in your package. All offers of settlement on your account are hereby rejected. Your Letter dated September 13, 2004 neither acts as a novation nor as an accord and satisfaction. Further attempts at a novation or an accord and satisfaction will be similarly rejected.



We request that you stop sending further documents of this sort to KeyBank. Despite that redemption documents you have sent to KeyBank, you will remain liable for repaying your debt. In the event that you fail to repay your debt, KeyBank will take all actions available, including the possible reporting of adverse information to the various credit reporting agencies and foreclosure of your property.



KeyBank is under no obligation to provide you with any responses or acknowledgements to any letters you might send. By not providing you with any reply, KeyBank is not admitting to the truth or falsity of any statements or claims you make in your correspondence. Further, no responding to your correspondence does not create any type of default, material misrepresentation, or dishonor on the part KeyBank. Your obligation to repay the amount owed under the terms of your extension of credit are not affected by KeyBanks’s response or lack of response to any correspondence you may send in.



Please feel free to contact our Collections and Recovery Department at xxx to make payment arrangements on your account. Should you have any further questions on your account, feel free to contact one of our customer represantitives at xxx



Sincerely

KeyBank Law Group









1. Due to outright rejection of my promissory note my debt is discharged according to the UCC § 3-603. TENDER OF PAYMENT, right?



2. paragraph 7 .. Your obligation to repay the amount owed under the terms of your extension of credit…did they just admit that they the bank extended me credit????? That’s a no-no for banks right?



3. Lien, Lien who’s got the Lien. I’m still befuddled on which way to go with the removal of Keybank as legal owner on the title. On the original bank of America document I didn’t check the box or initial the box that said I would give them security interest in the property whoopsie . Also my copy of the odometer disclosure release of interest by registered owner paperwork is signed only by me. However when I went to my dealer and checked my sales file per TILA (truth in lending act) their copy of this paperwork is signed. They signed it after I left. The application says on the left hand side that applicable sections not valid unless fully completed. Are they legally allowed to give me a copy of their unsigned copy and sign it later? Can I use this letter and a copy of the promissory note I sent as a way to sue for release of Lien?



As always thank you for your responses and I’m waiting on the schauf books.




INTERESTING DEVELOPMENT. FROM WHAT I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE TRYING TO DISCHARGE A CAR LOAN RIGHT? I'M SURPRISED YOU GOT SUCH A LENGTHY RESPONSE FROM THE LENDER.

IT'S FUNNY HOW THEY'RE TELLING YOU THEY'RE NOT A DEBT COLLECTOR.

IN MY CASE, I SENT TWO VALIDATION LETTERS AND THE ALLEGED LENDER JUST KEPT CALLING AND SENDING BILLS UNTIL A "SPECIAL INVESTIGATOR "

(I.E. THIRD PARTY DEBT COLLECTOR) WAS RETAINED.



BASICALLY, THE ISSUE HERE IS THE FRAUDULENT CONTRACT. THIS IS A SECURED DEBT CASE NOT JUST A CREDIT CARD.THE CAR DEALER GOT PAID WHEN YOU SIGNED THE PROMISSORY NOTE . THESE ALLEGED CREDITORS NEED TO PROVIDE PROOF OF THE ORIGINAL NOTE WITH YOUR SIGNATURE ON IT.



I'VE BEEN GOING BACK AN FORTH WITH THIS SPECIAL INVESTIGATOR FOR THE LAST THREE MONTHS AND THEY STILL CAN'T FIND THE ORIGINAL NOTE. THEY'VE TRIED TO PLAY ALL KINDS OF GAMES BUT STILL NO ORIGINAL CONTRACT.



CHECK OUT THE OTHER THREAD ON AUTO LOAN WHRE I POSTED MY CASE.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 09-27-2004, 12:44 PM
rushpat's Avatar
rushpat rushpat is offline
Mental Jujitsu
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Georgia
Posts: 722
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

Hmm... they claim they aren't subject to the FDCPA because they are a bank, not a debt collector.



Hmm... they continue to try to collect the debt, even though they say that they aren't a debt collector.



They then say that the FDCPA doesn't apply to them, but they go ahead, send copies of documents and claim they've just met the requirements of the FDCPA demand for validation.



These guys have identity issues....

Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 09-27-2004, 02:03 PM
Jerseee's Avatar
Jerseee Jerseee is offline
Come and Get Some!
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Texas
Posts: 2,837
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

All,



Actually they (Keybank) are correct. They are not debt collectors--yet. They are attempting to get payment from a note that has been assigned to them. Now the real question that one should be asking is....If the first offer was rejected, how in the world did keybank get it assigned to them?



Secondly, the letter they sent is full of admission. Now that one has tendered the VOD--a letter writing campaign should be underway. Demand certified verification fromt he 3 CRAs. Then you may want to ask that htey send your CPN back if they refused it as payment.



I bet they did not send it back with the rejection letter did they? HHhhhmmm, can you say theft?



You see the beauty of the CPN is this.....if they accept it--the alleged debt is satisfied. If they reject it, the alleged debt is discharged. SO they are in a catch 22. Read HJR 192 and read up on honor and dishonor of a note in a business law book, and in the UCC--you will be pleasantly surprised.
__________________
"FOR AS HE THINKETH IN HIS HEART, SO IS HE."
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 09-29-2004, 01:47 PM
joma44 joma44 is offline
Waking Up
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 23
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

Hey Jersee I dont understand this question.
Quote:
If the first offer was rejected, how in the world did keybank get it assigned to them
Could you re-ask it or explain the thought behind it?



Also on the certified verification....won't the bank just send the photocopied crap again this time to the CRA?



the rejection of my negotiable instrument is pretty cool. At the moment I'm working on my response and on the potential theft of my note. do you think there should there be a Notice of dishonor sent as well?
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 09-29-2004, 03:18 PM
Jerseee's Avatar
Jerseee Jerseee is offline
Come and Get Some!
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Texas
Posts: 2,837
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

Joma,



If you applied for a loan from me and I reject your application--how can another financial institution take that rejected application from another institution and accept it as if you applied for a "loan" with them?



If Bank A rejects an aaplication made out to them---how in the world can Bank M approve it and you never applied or contacted them for a "loan"?

__________________
"FOR AS HE THINKETH IN HIS HEART, SO IS HE."
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 09-30-2004, 02:32 AM
dashboy's Avatar
dashboy dashboy is offline
Practice Makes Perfect
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: California
Posts: 329
Response from Key Bank and Auto Loan

It may be that there is also a fair credit billing Act violation in the makes if they keep your promissory note but dont ledger it on the account within a certain time frame. Start thinking of some creative ways to impliment this while not disputing or argueing it (CAN YOU SAY COURTESY COPY?). Also I believe there might be a tax issue concerning this matter that maybe the IRS needs to be notified of. I thought you were an upstanding citizen who reported all crimes to the proper authorities? Also how the hell did keybank get your personal inf without your notification first? Who told BofA they had permission to pass your persoanl info to them with giving you notice? Are both of these clowns trading info from computer records that concerns you??



dash!
__________________
I just figured it out! It's all for free!
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Cites - Possession of Promissory Note Required suijuris Banks, Collectors, and CRAs 103 04-14-2008 02:09 PM
Cites - FDCPA (Title 15, Chapter 41, Subchapter V) suijuris Banks, Collectors, and CRAs 38 11-04-2007 03:54 PM
"Money" created out of thin air iamfreeru2 Banks, Collectors, and CRAs 253 07-15-2006 11:18 AM
auto loan title joma44 Banks, Collectors, and CRAs 109 03-19-2005 07:57 PM
BOE question Bank trying to get auto back Redline UCC 3 03-26-2004 06:20 PM


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:37 PM.
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 2.4.0
2003-2007 Copyright by Law Research Group, LLC Terms of Use | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Notice/Disclaimer