Go Back   Suijuris Forums > Educational & Learning > Banks, Collectors, and CRAs
User Name
Password

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 01-01-2005, 08:56 AM
redpilltaker's Avatar
redpilltaker redpilltaker is offline
Unplugged
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 82
They just won't drop it!!(long)

HI forum!!

Well, this is getting irritating.

Back in 1994-1995, I signed a promissary note with "The Apple student purchase Program", to buy some computer equipment while I was in school.

Like many Americans, in the Matrix, my wife and I struggled with money, credit and debt.

So, while on a peak of motivation to get out of debt back in 1999, my wife contacted Consumer Credit Counselling Services and made arrangements to see if they could help. They said that they could, and to contact all of our creditors and ask them if they would agree to work with the counselors.

Things were going well, as all the creditors were agreeable. My wife then contacted The Complete Source, who funded the computer loan...and the guy would not talk with her. He said that "they" don't work with CCCS and my wife asked, "Why? Everyone else will?...then what are we supposed to do?!" To which he replied, "Well, you can sell some of your stuff, or we will garnish your husband's wages!!" After which he hung up on my wife. Crying she called to plead again, and the guy hung up on her again!!

So, the protective husband gets home, the wife relays the story, I tell her that my labor contract at work speaks of excessive garnishments and that we are not going to put my employment at risk because these guys won't work with us, I said, "Then no one gets paid..." And I called a local flat rate bankruptcy attorney.

During the interview with the attorney, we went over the debts and assets, and this particular loan came up in the discussion....I explained that it was a purchase program for college students and that it appeared to be a consumer type debt to buy computer stuff...it was scheduled as a debt that may have collateral attached(or something like that)...

Long story a little shorter, we filed, no "creditors" attended the trustee meeting, no "creditors" challenged the dischargebility of the "debt" during the subsequent 90 days and the Chapter 7 was discharged in April, 2000.

So, now enter three different Collectors....the first one went away when I asked over the phone, "Exactly which part of the Bankruptcy code is your legal department relying on to ignore a dischage under a judge's signature?"
....good.

The second one, for the past couple of months on and off again, threwh in a curve ball and tried to claim that the "debt" was owed to a nonprofit organization, and as such the bankruptcy has no effect...to which I sent a letter stating that in my memory, this debt was issued by a bank in nebraska, that their client did not protest/assert any rights through the bankruptcy proceeding, I was going to presume that my attorney, the trustee and the judge were all competant to dischage their duties, I was going to stand on the court record and to cease and desist all future efforts to contact me....

NOW, number three has just stepped into the ring! I spoke with a nice "skip-tracer" last week before the holiday...and just yesterday I had a nice conversation with a gentleman that is from their legal office. They both tried to explain to me that the debt was funded by a nonprofit organization as a student loan. He went as far as to tell me that the original promissary note actually stated that I understood that it was a non-profit organization and that I could not file bankruptcy on the "debt"...At which time I told him that I would like to see the promissary note for several reasons:

I did not recognize who EduCap was, as I don't remember them mentioned in the paperwork.

The debt was included in the chapter seven with no challenges whatsoever, so I was thinking that the client may find themselves estopped by their lack of contest.

And in the worst case scenerio, the courts have said that a party is expected to mitigate any "damages" to themselves as soon as they are aware of the damage...along these lines, the SOL would probably start the clock back when I fell delinquent on the payments, 1998?. To this last issue he tried to say that the bankruptcy would have "reset" any time limits.

So, he said that he had to order the promissary note from WellsFargo...and that it would be several weeks before I got it. I thanked him and told him in closing, that at this point, I would certainly need proof of his claim since I believe the debt was discharged.

So, gentle reader, what say ye?

Are they estopped by aquiescense through the Chapter 7 because they asserted no rights to challenge the debt's dischargability?

Was there not a reasonable expectation that my attorney, the trustee, and the judge used due diligence in the completion of their expected tasks?

Doesn't the filing of a bankruptcy petition only temporarily prevent collection efforts by the "creditors" until the discharge?

Why this could be the easiest route is that in my state, contract SOL is six years...so I would like to calculate from the time that "account" was in default until present date, while subtracting the time between filing and the discharge(in months), because I am thinking that if the collector doesn't file suit soon, the six years will be up...

And, if the WellsFargo ends up being the "holder in due course", they may have a hard time proving some sort of nonprofit status....hmmm?

Thanks for reading this, and I anxiously await the ideas and responses from the group....because you are such a "lively" bunch and so, so sma..smart, yeah! and fun too!!!

Still "enjoying" the red pill,

RPT
__________________
"In life there are many quotients, and I hope I find the mean..." Tremonti/Stapp
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 01-01-2005, 04:07 PM
iamfreeru2 iamfreeru2 is offline
Come and Get Some!
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,685
RPT,

It is my understanding a student loan is not dischargeable in a Bankruptcy and the fact you did not dispute it and listed it as a debt makes you liable for it. It is considered an unsecure priority debt and cannot be discharged. Someone else more knowledgeable about such things may want to chime in.

iamfreru2
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 01-01-2005, 08:58 PM
redpilltaker's Avatar
redpilltaker redpilltaker is offline
Unplugged
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 82
Hey iam!!

Yeah, this debt was scheduled under the heading of, "Creditors holding secured claims"....

I think my issue lies in whether these folks were in fact nonprofit, whether or not a computer purchase falls under some definition of a student loan, whether or not these folks are estopped for not resonding within the 90 days after the trustee's meeting....one of the court forms directed interested parties to come forward with any issues of dischargebility, execptions, and exemptions....

So, right now I am waiting to see when I get the copy of the promissary note...then I will want to see the original, and then I may look into some fraud angles....and above those issues, how would wells fargo ever claim to be a nonprofit organization?!

This is the third collection agency to bother me about this over the years, no one has started a suit to date...we'll see...

Thanks Bro!!

RPT
__________________
"In life there are many quotients, and I hope I find the mean..." Tremonti/Stapp
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 01-02-2005, 02:56 AM
iamfreeru2 iamfreeru2 is offline
Come and Get Some!
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 1,685
RPT,

I do not think Wells Fargo is claiming to be non-profit. I think the group that said they loaned you funds is claiming non-profit status and used Wells Fargo as their agent. Now if they never filed a claim with the BK court then you have a definite issue. You need to be finding out if they ever sent a claim in and if not I would say they have a problem. I know the court is more lenient when it comes to "student loans" or "taxes." Hope you get something you can hang them by their 'nads with.

iamfreeru2
Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Opportunities men and women RickA End Days of America 2 09-02-2005 07:43 PM
Is the value of Pi = 3? BoyntonStu Religion 61 06-19-2005 02:25 PM
Incarcerated and threatened. squirrel Misc. Discussion 20 03-22-2005 08:53 AM


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:26 AM.
Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 2.4.0
2003-2007 Copyright by Law Research Group, LLC Terms of Use | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Notice/Disclaimer